Couples Challenge Marriage Discrimination in California
Legal Groups Allege Denial of Marriage Licenses Violates State ConstitutionFor Immediate Release: March 12, 2004
San Francisco – This morning, the ACLU of
Northern California, along with the National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR),
the ACLU of Southern California and Lambda Legal, filed a lawsuit arguing that
denying same-sex couples the right to marry violates the California
Constitution’s guarantees of equality, liberty, and privacy.
The suit was filed on behalf of six same-sex couples, five of whom had
upcoming appointments to obtain marriage licenses at San Francisco City Hall.
The couples had their appointments cancelled as a result of the California
Supreme Court’s order issued yesterday directing San Francisco to stop issuing
marriage licenses to same-sex couples.
Two organizations, Our Family Coalition and Equality California, are also
parties in the case.
“We are eager to take on this historic opportunity
to end marriage discrimination in California,” said Tamara Lange, staff attorney
for the ACLU. “Marriage is a commitment. It is about sharing, love, trust, and
compromise. Two adults who make this personal choice to form a life-long
commitment should not be denied the right to marry just because they are gay or
lesbian.”
The couples in the suit:
- Lancy Woo and Cristy Chung have been in a committed
relationship for 16 years. They have a five-year-old daughter, Olivia. Lancy and
Cristy had an appointment to get married at San Francisco City Hall on March
30th.
- Joshua Rymer and Timothy Frazer have been in a committed
relationship for more than 10 years. Joshua and Tim met in 1994 and exchanged
wedding rings in a private ceremony in 1995. They had an appointment to get
married at San Francisco City Hall at 2 p.m. on March 17th and were planning to
have a small ceremony at City Hall, to be followed by a reception and renewal of
vows at their home in Sonoma.
- Jewell Gomez and Diane Sabin have been together for 11
years. Jewell is a writer and the Program Director at the San Francisco Arts
Commission. Diane is a chiropractor. Diane and Jewell had obtained an
application for a marriage license and intended to marry.
- Myra Beals and Ida Matson are 61 and 68 years old,
respectively, and have been in a committed relationship for 27 years. They had
an appointment to get married at San Francisco City Hall on Friday, March 12,
2004 – one day after the California Supreme Court ordered San Francisco to stop
issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Friends and family had made plans
to join them in San Francisco on March 12 to celebrate their marriage with them.
- Arthur Frederick Adams and Devin Wayne Baker have been in a
committed relationship for three and a half years. Arthur and Devin had an
appointment to get married at San Francisco City Hall at 3 p.m. on March 11th.
They bought wedding rings and arrived at San Francisco City Hall about 2:45 p.m.
on March 11, along with several family members and friends who were there to
witness and celebrate their wedding. Arthur and Devin were in the process of
completing an application for a marriage license when they were informed that no
further marriage licenses would be issued to same-sex couples.
- Jeanne Rizzo and Pali Cooper have been together in a
committed relationship for 15 years. Jeanne and Pali had an appointment to get
married at San Francisco City Hall at 3:00 p.m. on March 11th. They arrived at
San Francisco City Hall on that date, accompanied by about fifty family members
and friends, including many who had traveled from out of state to attend their
wedding celebration. Jeanne and Pali were on the steps of City Hall with their
family members when they were told that no more marriage licenses could be
granted.
The two organizational plaintiffs in the suit:
- Our Family Coalition is a San Francisco Bay Area
organization dedicated to promoting the civil rights and well being of families
with lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender members.
- Equality California is the leading state-wide advocacy
group protecting the needs and interests of same-sex couples and their children
in California.