Civil Rights Groups File Federal Lawsuit to Block Unlawful and Life-Endangering Immigration Arrests

Media Contact:, (415) 621-2493

Article Media

Today, Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus and the ACLU Foundation of Northern California filed a class-action lawsuit demanding that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) stop its illegal practice of using third-party contractor, G4S Secure Solutions, Inc., to arrest people at jails and prisons to funnel them into the deportation pipeline.

Federal law prohibits ICE from using private security to make immigration arrests, a fact that immigration officials have willfully ignored.

The complaint was filed in the United States District Court, Central District of California on behalf of plaintiff, Gabriela Solano. It seeks an injunction against the head of ICE and immigration officials who run the Los Angeles and San Francisco Field Offices, barring ICE from using private contractors to make arrests.

Gabriela Solano is a 48-year-old lawful permanent resident and survivor of domestic violence who was granted parole because of her demonstrated rehabilitation during her 22 years of incarceration. However, because of ICE’s unlawful private contractor policy, she faces imminent arrest by G4s once released from prison.

"I've been dreaming of being reunited with my family and community for so long, and now it could finally happen. But the fear of being arrested by G4S, locked in an ICE detention center, and possibly deported to Mexico, keeps me up at night,” Solano said. “I was brought here to the U.S. at the age of two and my closest family is here. This is where I hope to build a new life with the second chance I've been given."

According to the complaint, since at least 2016, ICE has sent G4S contractors to prisons and jails throughout most of California to arrest hundreds of people and transfer them from state and local custody to immigration custody. Many have been cruelly ripped away from their families and sent to out-of-state ICE prisons ravaged by COVID-19.

Ny Nourn was born in a refugee camp in Thailand after her mother fled genocide in Cambodia. She was sentenced to life in prison for failing to stop a murder committed by her abusive partner weeks after she turned 18. In May 2017, after the state of California deemed her suitable for release, she was arrested by a G4S employee and detained by ICE for six months. She was granted protection from removal by an immigration judge and was later granted a full and unconditional pardon of her conviction by Governor Newsom. Nourn currently works at Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus as a community advocate.

“For weeks up until my release, I was overwhelmed with stress and fear that I was going to be re-arrested all over again by ICE, face worse prison conditions in immigration detention, and may never see freedom in America again, the only home I’ve known since I was 5 years old,” Nourn said. “On the day of my release, instead of being reunited with my family, I was arrested by a G4S officer who placed me in chains and an unmarked vehicle. All I could do was hold back my tears with feelings of shock, fear, numbness, and disappointment.”

The State of California is aware of G4S’s abusive practices yet continues to voluntarily collaborate and turn Californians over to G4S. Further, state officials’ practice of continuing transfers to ICE during the COVID-19 pandemic, despite the widely documented, gruesome conditions in ICE detention centers, exhibits a blatant disregard for their constitutional obligation to safeguard the welfare of those in their custody.

Jenny Zhao, a litigation staff attorney at Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus, said that ICE flouts the law every day and California officials are complicit in this behavior. “Fully aware that ICE’s use of contractors is unlawful and dangerous, Governor Newsom has refused to stop collaborating with ICE,” Zhao said. “Instead, he vetoed a bill in 2019, that would have prohibited state prisons from facilitating these arrests. We don’t need more rhetoric about California’s leadership; we need the Governor to take action and stop criminalizing immigrants and refugees."

Vasudha Talla, Immigrants' Rights Program Director at the ACLU of Northern California, said ICE shouldn’t take people into custody period, let alone use G4s which has a long history of mistreating individuals during transport to and from immigration detention centers. “Government funds shouldn’t be used to break up California families,” Talla said. “The Biden administration should revisit the current policies and ultimately cut off these pathways to deportation.”

In one horrific case, in 2019, the ACLU Foundation of Northern California filed a lawsuit against G4s on behalf of four women who were shackled by their hands and feet in a windowless van in scorching heat, causing some of them to struggle for breath and fear they would die.

Munger, Tolles & Olson LLP, is co-counsel.

File Under

Main Article Content